Pick diamond painting if you want a relaxing, no-mess craft you can pick up for ten minutes and put down again, and a sparkly picture at the end. Pick paint by numbers if you want something that looks like a painting and teaches a little brush control. Kits cost about the same on Amazon. A diamond painting takes longer per square inch, which makes it the better buy if you want hours of something to do and the worse one if you want it on the wall by Sunday.
How we compared them
Maggie Rose Bennett, our diamond painting and craft contributor, built this comparison from the kits themselves rather than from craft-store marketing. On October 21, 2026 we pulled Amazon's results for adult paint-by-numbers kits: 44 unsponsored kits showing about 13,500 bought in the past month, 40 of them at 100 or more. Their box contents come from the listings below. Diamond painting times come from our calculator; we also read the comparison pages that rank on Google for this question, all of them written by companies that sell one craft or the other.
This is a "How we pick" comparison built from listings and published sources. Where a number is a seller's estimate, we say so. How we research.
Side by side
| Diamond painting | Paint by numbers | |
|---|---|---|
| What you do | Press resin drills onto a glue-coated canvas, matching symbols | Brush acrylic paint into numbered areas |
| In the box | Coded canvas under film, drills in bags, pen, wax, tray | Printed canvas (some pre-framed), paint pots, 3 brushes, color guide |
| Skill | Matching and patience | Steady edges and even coats; improves with practice |
| Setup and cleanup | Lift the film, open a bag; cover the canvas when you stop | Water cup, paper towel, brush washing, pot lids |
| Waiting | None | Drying between neighboring colors and coats |
| Time for 12 x 16 in | About 38 hours (round drills) to 48 hours (square) at 350 an hour | No measured figure; sellers say faster than diamond painting |
| Fixing a mistake | Lift the drill and replace it | Let it dry, paint over; light over dark may need two coats |
| Finished look | Sparkling mosaic, best under a lamp or window | Matte or satin painting, visible brushwork |
| Detail | Limited by drill size (2.5 or 2.8 mm) | Limited by the printed areas; faces read better |
| Pets and toddlers | Loose drills are small parts | Wet paint and water cups get knocked over |
What a session actually looks like
The biggest difference isn't the materials. It's the rhythm.
That's why diamond painting works in front of the TV or in ten-minute gaps, and why paint by numbers suits a cleared table and an afternoon. Paint On Numbers Canada, which sells both, makes the same point in its comparison: setup under a minute for diamond painting, a few minutes for paint by numbers, and a wait for each layer to dry before painting next to it.

Time to finish
For diamond painting the math is simple: count the drills, divide by your pace. A 12 x 16 inch round-drill kit with a half-inch border holds about 13,464 drills, so 38.5 hours at 350 an hour; the square-drill version holds about 16,872, or 48 hours. Our guide to how long a diamond painting takes has every common size.
Paint by numbers has no equivalent count, because time depends on how many numbered areas the design has and how many coats each needs. The figures published online are all sellers' estimates. Paint On Numbers Canada says a 16 x 20 inch paint-by-numbers kit takes 15 to 40 hours. Crafty By Numbers, which sells paint-by-numbers kits, says diamond painting takes two to three times longer for the same size, and cites no study. Treat both as rough. What holds up is the direction: for the same canvas, a diamond painting is the longer project.
So the cost per hour favors diamond painting. Kits sit in the same low price band on Amazon (the buttons below show today's prices), and a diamond kit keeps you busy for more evenings.
Fixing mistakes
A wrong drill comes back off with tweezers or the pen tip, and a fresh one goes in. The glue under it is usually still tacky unless the canvas has been uncovered for weeks. Our guide to fixing diamond painting mistakes covers lifting drills without pulling the glue.
In paint by numbers you paint over the mistake once it's dry. Dark over light covers in one coat; light over dark usually takes more than one, which is why Crafty By Numbers advises painting light colors before dark ones. Paint that bleeds over a printed line can't be lifted, only covered.
What ends up on the wall
A finished paint by numbers looks like a painting. Brushwork and soft color steps let it handle faces, fur and skies well, and it frames like any canvas. A diamond painting looks like a mosaic. Up close you see every drill; from across the room you see color and sparkle, and that sparkle depends on light, so it looks best near a window or under a lamp. Full-drill kits cover the whole canvas, partial-drill kits leave a printed background (our 5D diamond painting explainer covers both).
For framing, a painted canvas takes a standard frame. A diamond painting usually gets an open or deep frame; see how to frame diamond art.
Who each craft suits
| If the person... | Choose |
|---|---|
| Wants to relax with the TV on | Diamond painting |
| Wants to learn something about painting | Paint by numbers |
| Works at a shared table that must be cleared for dinner | Diamond painting (cover the canvas and close the tray) |
| Wants a portrait or pet face that reads well | Paint by numbers, or a large custom diamond kit |
| Has a toddler or a dog that eats things | Either, with care; drills are small parts and paint spills |
| Has unsteady hands | Diamond painting; a drill can be lifted and placed again |
| Wants a finished gift by the weekend | A small paint by numbers, or a mini diamond kit |
Plenty of crafters keep one of each going: a painting for weekends, a diamond kit for weeknights.
Kits to try either craft
For a first diamond painting, the BYGFHLYW beach flower kit is one of the most-bought adult kits on Amazon right now, at about 1,000 a month with 4.7 stars from more than 1,500 ratings; the listing describes acrylic drills and a canvas with clear symbols. Our beginner kits guide has more, sorted by size and drill shape.
For paint by numbers, the Yezavesu framed 10 x 10 inch kit arrives stretched on a wooden frame with acrylic paints, three brushes and hanging hooks, so it hangs the day you finish. The CHWGLFGG wildflower kit is the bigger 16 x 20 inch option, unframed. The three brushes in most kits are coarse; a set of fine detail brushes (rounds from 5/0 to 8, per the Nicpro listing) makes the small numbered areas much easier.
Quick answers for the other "vs" questions
Diamond art vs diamond painting: the same craft under two names. Crystal Art is one brand of it, and our Crystal Art vs diamond painting page covers what changes with that brand.
Diamond painting vs cross stitch: both work from a grid and a color chart, and diamond painting kits use the DMC numbering that embroidery floss uses (our DMC color chart lists them). Cross stitch is thread on fabric, slower to learn, and can show finer detail. Some diamond painting listings say "5D diamond painting cross stitch"; nothing is stitched in those kits.
Diamond painting vs bedazzling: bedazzling has no canvas or pattern. You glue loose rhinestones onto an object you choose. See bedazzling kits.
Diamond painting vs pearl painting: pearl kits are diamond painting kits with glossy round beads in parts of the design. See pearl art kits.
Diamond painting vs perler beads: perler (fuse) beads are small plastic tubes set on a pegboard and melted together with an iron, which makes a stiff piece you can pick up. Diamond painting stays on its canvas and needs no heat.
The decision
If you're buying for yourself and you want something to do most evenings, start with a diamond painting. If you're buying for someone who has ever said they wish they could paint, give them paint by numbers. Not sure? Small kits of both are cheap enough to buy one of each, and the one they finish first is your answer. New to diamond painting? Our how-to guide walks through the first session.
Sources: Amazon listings for each kit above and Amazon search results for adult paint-by-numbers kits, checked October 21, 2026; Paint On Numbers Canada, "Paint by Numbers vs Diamond Painting: A Complete Guide" (June 29, 2025); Crafty By Numbers, "Which Finishes Faster? Paint by Numbers vs Diamond Painting" (September 13, 2026). Diamond painting drill counts and hours from our calculator at 350 drills an hour.