Diamond Art Club is the best diamond painting company for most people who want a kit worth framing: it ships from Indiana, promises to replace missing drills for the life of the kit, and has the strongest review record of any brand we checked. Diamond Dotz is the pick if you want a brand you can buy in a store. For a cheap first kit, skip the brand sites and buy a well-rated budget kit on Amazon. And read the shipping page of any stand-alone store before paying, because two of the six companies below ship most orders from overseas in two to eight weeks.
Quick picks
| Best premium brand on Amazon | Diamond Art Club Stained Glass Flower | Amazon |
|---|---|---|
| A Diamond Dotz kit on Amazon | Diamond Dotz Pony Dreams | Amazon |
| Best Crystal Art pick | Crystal Art Harry Potter Sticker Album Starter Pack | Amazon |
| Budget comparison | CHWGLFGG 5D Landscape Kit | Amazon |
How we compared these companies
On October 13, 2026 we read each company's own policy pages, then recorded its Trustpilot score and review count the same day. For brands that sell on Amazon, we pulled their listings to confirm contents and sales. We didn't rank on canvas softness or drill sparkle, because every brand claims both and we haven't painted a kit from each. We ranked on things you can check before you pay.
This is a "How we pick" guide. No brand paid to be included or sent us kits. How we research.
A note on what already ranks for this search: the top list we found is labeled as a paid local advertisement, and a sourcing blog's "top 3" names no source for its sales rankings. Neither tells you what happens when your parcel is late.
Six companies side by side
| Company | Ships from | Delivery (US) | Returns | Missing drills | Trustpilot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diamond Art Club | Avon, Indiana | Aims to ship within 24 business hours | 30 days from delivery, unused | Lifetime protection (not clearance) | 4.8 (4,176) |
| Diamond Dotz | Not stated; US store ships US and Canada | 1 to 3 days processing, then within 7 business days | 30 days from order, pre-approved | Free, even for retail kits | 3.8 (5) |
| Heartful Diamonds | Own factory in China; based in Australia and the US | 6 to 10 business days after dispatch | Refund or replacement within 90 days of delivery if faulty or unsatisfactory | Free once approved | 4.6 (66) |
| Crystal Art (Craft Buddy) | UK brand | Via Amazon or US hobby shops | Seller's policy | Couldn't verify | Not checked |
| Paint With Diamonds | Mostly Henan Province, China; some US stock | 30 to 60 days average; US-stock kits 2 to 4 business days | 50 days, custom excluded | Free replacements | 1.8 (15) |
| Diamond Painting Pro | Overseas facilities; some US stock | 7 to 28 days average plus processing | 60 days from purchase, custom excluded | Contact support with DMC code | 1.6 (64) |
From each company's own policy pages and Trustpilot, October 13, 2026. Trustpilot counts in parentheses. Profiles with under 20 reviews tell you very little. Craft Buddy's site didn't load for us on the check date.
The companies, one by one
Diamond Art Club: best overall
The policy column is where DAC pulls ahead: a US warehouse, a written lifetime promise on missing drills, an adhesive warranty, and 4,176 Trustpilot reviews averaging 4.8. It sells artist and licensed designs (Disney and Star Wars among them) in round and square, plus specialty drills like AB and Fairy Dust. The main complaints on Trustpilot are slow support replies and delays in busy periods, and it costs several times more than a budget kit. Full details in our Diamond Art Club review.
Diamond Dotz: best for buying in a store
Diamond Dotz (from Needleart World) is the brand most likely to be on a shelf near you; its FAQ names Walmart. It replaces missing drills even for kits bought from a retailer. Two things to know: of the 420 canvas kits on its site, 257 are partial drill, and its color codes start at A01 in each kit instead of matching DMC numbers. See our Diamond Dotz review.
Heartful Diamonds: best stand-alone site for custom kits
Heartful Diamonds is upfront about where its kits come from: made on demand in its own factory in China. It's also the most generous on returns of the six: a refund or replacement within 90 days of delivery for faulty or unsatisfactory kits. Custom kits take 5 to 7 business days to make before shipping, US delivery is 6 to 10 business days after dispatch, and standard shipping is free over $80. Its Trustpilot score was 4.6 from 66 reviews. It doesn't sell on Amazon that we could find, so here's the official site, not an affiliate link: heartfuldiamonds.com.
Crystal Art: best for cards and pre-framed canvases
Crystal Art is Craft Buddy's UK brand of diamond painting, best known for 18 x 18 cm card kits, Harry Potter sticker albums and 30 x 30 cm canvases that come mounted on a wooden frame. In the US it turns up on Amazon and in hobby shops, usually with few ratings. Our Crystal Art vs diamond painting guide explains the formats.
Paint With Diamonds: big catalog, slow shipping
Paint With Diamonds has a large catalog of round and square kits, full or partial, from 20 x 20 cm up to 90 cm wide, and it offers free replacement diamonds. Its FAQ is clear that most kits ship from Henan Province, China, with average delivery of 30 to 60 days to the US, apart from a small set of US-stock kits that arrive in 2 to 4 business days. Its unclaimed Trustpilot profile showed 1.8 from 15 reviews, mostly about delivery and refunds. Only order if the kit is in the fast-shipping collection or you can wait two months.
Diamond Painting Pro: skip for anything urgent or custom
A real store with a poor review record: 1.6 on Trustpilot from 64 reviews, with complaints about month-plus waits and refused refunds. Its policies say it ships from overseas in 7 to 28 days and won't refund custom kits. Our Diamond Painting Pro review has the details and a late-order checklist.
Where diamond painting kits are actually made
People search "diamond painting factory" because they suspect every brand buys from the same place. Partly true. Heartful Diamonds and Paint With Diamonds both say their kits come from facilities in China, and Diamond Painting Pro ships from "custom printing facilities located overseas". Diamond Art Club describes itself as US-based, ships from Indiana and says it makes its resin in-house, but its pages don't say where canvases are printed. What a brand adds on top of the factory is real, though: who charts the design, whether the art is licensed, how many spare drills go in the bag, and whether anyone answers when drills are missing.
Brands you can buy on Amazon
Amazon is the easiest place to compare, because the return process is the same whoever the seller is. These are the brand listings we'd start with, plus one budget kit for contrast.
Diamond Art Club Stained Glass Flower
DAC's best-selling Amazon kit when we checked (about 700 bought last month, 4.8 stars, #15 in Diamond Painting Kits). A sensible size for a first premium kit, with the brand's better pen and tray.
- Canvas13 x 13 in, full drill
- Drillsround, 53 colors incl. AB and Fairy Dust
- ToolsTwist & Pick applicator with multi-placers, stackable tray
Why it stands out
- Specialty drills included
- Strong rank and rating
Think twice if
- Costs several times more than a budget kit of similar size
Diamond Dotz Pony Dreams
Diamond Dotz kits are scarce on Amazon; this small partial-drill kit is one of the few, with just four ratings. It shows the brand's style well. For more choice, use the brand's own site.
- Canvas11 x 11 in
- Drillsround
- Coveragepartial drill
- Includescolor chart, tray, stylus, wax caddy
Why it stands out
- Brand tools included
- Short project
Think twice if
- Very few ratings
- Partial drill, so less sparkle
Crystal Art Harry Potter Sticker Album Starter Pack
The best-selling Crystal Art item on Amazon on our check date, about 400 bought last month. A collectible album of gem stickers rather than a wall piece.
- Album25 x 20 cm
- Ages8+
- LicenseHarry Potter
Why it stands out
- Licensed
- Good for kids 8 and up
Think twice if
- 4.2 stars
- Refill packs are random designs
CHWGLFGG 5D Landscape Kit
A typical well-rated budget kit: about 2,000 bought last month and a small fraction of a branded kit's cost. The listing promises a replacement kit if drills or tools are missing. Good for finding out whether you like the hobby.
- Canvas13.7 x 13.7 in
- Drillsround, full drill, 26 facets (listing)
- Ratings4.7 from 1,926
Why it stands out
- Cheap way to start
- Lots of ratings
Think twice if
- No artist credit or license
- Budget-kit risks: creases, patchy glue
How to judge any company's kits before you buy
A Lazada buying guide we read lists sensible criteria, and they match what hobby bloggers report from side-by-side comparisons. Check the listing or product page for:
- an inventory sheet with DMC codes, so missing colors are easy to report and leftovers match other kits
- glue that runs to the edge of the design, so border drills stay put
- the printed image size, not just the canvas size, which includes a blank border
- buyer photos of the finished piece, not just a digital mockup
- a license note on character art
- whether the canvas ships rolled or folded (folded leaves creases)
Our square vs round guide helps with the drill choice, and the best kits for adults list applies these checks to specific kits.
Which company for which situation
| Situation | Company |
|---|---|
| A gift for someone who already paints | Diamond Art Club |
| Needed within a week | Diamond Art Club, Diamond Dotz, or any Amazon listing with fast delivery |
| A custom photo kit from a brand site | Heartful Diamonds (90-day refund or replacement for faulty kits) |
| Buying in a store | Diamond Dotz; see where to buy diamond painting kits |
| A child aged 8 to 12 | Crystal Art cards or stickers, or Diamond Dotz's Dotzies line |
| The cheapest first try | A budget Amazon kit; see our cheap kits guide |
| You can wait two months for a bargain | Paint With Diamonds (non-US stock) |
If you only remember one thing
Find the words "ships from" before you check out. A US warehouse and a written missing-drill promise prevent most of the bad experiences people post about. On that test, Diamond Art Club is the safest premium choice and Diamond Dotz the easiest to buy locally.
Policies from diamondartclub.com, diamonddotz.com, heartfuldiamonds.com, paintwithdiamonds.com and diamondpaintingpro.com; Trustpilot scores; Amazon listings. All checked October 13, 2026. How we research · Affiliate disclosure